From Dust to Dust
Apr. 13th, 2025 07:47 pmOnce again, I return to the Burnt Hive to retrieve and compile the tales that precede us. And once again, the Hives’ oft-occlusive nature ensured it was a proper ordeal for me. No ideological squabbles this time, thankfully, and nothing I needed to prowl every Hive for, either. No, this time, what got in the way was the simple fact the average Shumhaq is irritatingly apathetic to their own history, even beyond the usual day-at-a-time Subterraneum citizen. As if looking at their founding, or the past beyond it, were a waste of time, or worse, an admission of defeat. A focus on the present is all fine and good, but I feel the need to request they cultivate some historical curiosity.
Thankfully, however, some do care. Much as their historians seemed to save their tales in an oddly resentful manner, as if writing down their grudges… And then, there were the One-Hivers. They had an abundance of useful scraps in their more incendiary material, but stripping the virulent biases off them was less than pleasant. But a source is a source, whatever their reasons to preserve may have been. Here, the result.
Do you know what death is?
It’s not an ending. A spirit might leave, or it might not, it might never be there to begin with[1]. The body stops moving, stops reacting, stops doing, but it doesn’t stop being. The only difference between a corpse and a body is what’s alive in it. But it ain’t really the start of a cycle, either[2]. Spiral, at best. That body won’t start moving again, you’ll just have it rot and get eaten up. The spirit, if any, it’ll move away from it, from us, from everything, never to come back. It’ll bring life to others, but you won’t have what you had ever again. It’ll never be the same.
What death is, then, is a split. Just like everything else. As time goes, everything splits, one thing from the next, and two things into many more. “To dust we return”, as they say, but they don’t cover just how many tiny fractures and splits it takes to bring a living being back to dust. But you might ask that, now that you’re aware of the question. And the answer is always “more than you think”. There is no true way to mend every cut to its fullest extent, something is always missing. There’s always another cut you missed. From something as simple as shattered glass, to death itself, you can never put it all back together to the way it was. Not completely.
One of the biggest reasons for that is, someone out there’s making sure those cuts stay that way.
Every separation, every severance between one thing and the rest, is looked over. Surveyed. Accounted for, along with the pieces it creates. Because whoever put it all together in one place once is done with it all, if that one ever existed, but someone needs to oversee it as it comes apart. Make sure it comes apart when it has to – not one moment before the cut, and not one moment after. And most of all, keeping the most important separations, all the important splits, the way they are. Let nothing be rolled back. Make sure it’s all dust in the end, the thinnest of dust, when all is said and done.
Why? In a way, it’s simple. Because the closest thing to where it all began, to the great pile of everything that started it all, is the thinnest, most basic, most finely sieved dust of all, where even size and weight and distance have been sliced so thin they’re hardly even there anymore. Where every last component has been separated and reduced to its minimum expression, until there’s nothing left to shed. Get all that dust together, gathered as tight as something so tiny it barely has a size can be, and all of a sudden, you have… everything, together again, at once, in a single place.
But it’s not the Surveyor[3]’s job to do that part. The Surveyor’s job is to make sure it gets there. Neatly, cleanly and properly. And most importantly, evenly.
The biggest reason why every split must remain as such, every cut unmended, is so that no one piece is bigger than the other in the end. Not one mote should outsize the other, and none of them should clump back together into something even resembling a greater, singular mass. The process is not over, and the Surveyor’s work isn’t done, until every particle, every amalgam, has been trimmed back into its separate parts. And what is an amalgam but a mass of particles that’ve tried to mend the cuts between them, in the end? Even those you’d never consider cuts because they were seemingly always there, or those that are too esoteric to consider them such at first. They may not count for you, but the Surveyor knows. The Surveyor watches, making sure even now, such mendings don’t happen.
You might wonder now how this one takes care of such things. How things are kept apart, or separated if they risk being gathering spots, focal points for one such amalgamation. You might think the Surveyor has a blade, or shears, to be wielded when something is stubbornly resisting its moment to split at last, or worse, actually mending a cut that should’ve been complete. And you would be very wrong for that assumption. Not every knife can split a stone. A knife that could do that, cannot split dust from air. And a knife that could do that, cannot split a city from its fortune, or a mother from her child, or an idea from its believers[4]. And a knife that could do that cannot split a stone, and we’re back where we began.
More importantly, a knife cannot stop most of those from coming right back together either.
So what’s the Surveyor use? Something that’s tailor-made for the split that must be done. Something forged from the materials available, which is everything. Something that will remain, and keep things split, even when it’s in a subtle way you can’t quite see. A chisel.
Sounds simple, doesn’t it? It is, yet it isn’t. Let me give you an example.
Once, it did happen, or try to. Something, someone, tried to clump things back together into one, and it was working. A grand agglomeration. One mind, barely even a mind, with an ever-growing body that just couldn’t be taken apart by those it was pulling in, devouring, assimilating. Not fast enough. Or maybe it was several bodies, joined together by a mind like strings? It was close enough to a singular thing, and it was growing quickly. Learning how to pull in everything, too. Material and immaterial. Maybe even started pulling in spirits, too. Thought as well. But it was all coming apart and becoming more of it. More mass, more of that singular mind, if you could even call it that. And when distance was there, it just stretched across it to reach what was next, and dug in too. And the bigger it got, the more it figured out how to pull in…
Nothing that was trying to survive in there, keep itself from being pulled in, was getting much done. It was just too big, there was too much of it, and anything they could take out, it’d pull right back in. Nothing to reason with either, it was just one thing, barely thinking, wanting to grow. Like a mold, if it was just a single creature, with just enough thought to reach out and grab things yet to die. And none of the cuts were deep enough to work with. All superficial, all barely trimming…
So the Surveyor went deeper. Reached into the thing’s mind, such as it was. Gathered it. Sharpened it. Made a chisel of pure thought, pure reason, pure sentience.
And drove it right through the center of this amalgam[5].
It split like glass. Cracks spread throughout it, as it started to think. As parts of it joined by these idle strings of mind started having their own thoughts. And the cracks spread further. One, to several, to millions, as whole segments started to disagree, then sub-segments, then actual individuals within the whole. And just like glass, it didn’t stop until it all came apart, as a grand amalgam, a grand thing, became nothing more than a mass of… people, with little in common between them other than some biology, and a shared experience where they couldn’t even think. No gods, no flag, no nation, just that.
And the Surveyor stepped back and looked upon a job well done. All schedules had been thrown off, things would take longer. But it was progressing as it all should. Barely even needed to intervene after that, these new peoples would do the rest of the splitting. And they did, too.
You’re wondering now why the Surveyor is so adamant. Why these splits must happen. Maybe things can’t restart properly if the balance is off. Maybe one giant amalgam of everything, biased to one side, to itself, a lattice or a blob rather than the dust it ought to be, just ain’t something you can start again with. Maybe it’ll be predictable if it’s done anyways, if it can be done at all. But we don’t know. All we know is, that’s how the Severing Surveyor works.
[1]I took care to keep the older versions of these tales and their scraps for this, and while their date was entirely uncertain those passages that alluded to spirit were entirely speculative, indicating this was before the Subterraneum made it clear such things exist. Mainly when they have nowhere to go.
[2]Soldiers of the Resurgent Hive (SRH) material actively used the word “rawark” for this, the Pact’s word for (life) cycle, and took the bother to add an immediate translation, as if to directly aim the following refutation. Every other source I found simply used the Shumhaq word.
[3]Here, terminology differs between regular and One-Hiver sources. The former uses the word “Nasharuq”, an old word descended from one of many terms for “master (crafter)”, which spawned a verb for “supervise, for approval or denial” and got retroactively altered in turn. The latter explicitly use “Druvhryk”, the word for “headsman (executioner)”. On a less charged note, all versions referred to the entity by name every time, going out of their way to avoid pronouns, and so I’ve replicated the effect here.
[4]All direct examples from the sources I had, but I had to trim them down significantly, as most of them used several more, not all of them especially functional in my eyes. SRH materials on the matter (from which I took the middle example of mother and child) seemed to delight in elaboration here, with some bitter undercurrents I didn’t find proper to include.
[5]The tone used in this and the following segment was one I tried to balance, between the stories from Shumhaq historians often taking a tone either awed or even triumphant, and those from the SRH who seemed to twist it into some manner of injustice. Not a tragedy, but seemingly something to resent the culprit for.
-Excerpt from “Who is the Lord Below? A Treatise on the Radiant and Cthonic”, authored by ‘the Ever-Restless Nirrhamidh’ (assumed pseudonym; author not yet identified and under active investigation)